The Case of Nick Shirley | Utah, 2025

In what should have been a routine moment outside an Utah “Hands Off” protest, one man found himself targeted not for anything did to them, but for what strangers suspected he believed because he dared question them. This suspicion was aroused by his wearing of a suit and having recording equipment, “who wears a suit to a protest” says one protester.

Nick Shirley, a private citizen, approached the courthouse lawn without incident. He was calm, quiet, and entirely within his rights. But a group of protesters suspecting he held conservative views formed a human barricade to block his path. When he turned to leave, they boxed him in, shouted over him, and weaponized false accusations, screaming “he’s assaulting me” while putting their hands on him and preventing him from moving as he tried to walk away.

Nick never raised his voice. Never retaliated. Never pushed back.

He simply tried to navigate out of the crowd while strangers attempted to criminalize his presence.

This is not protest. It’s persecution.

Protesting is a protected right. So is movement in a public space. But what took place in Utah was not civil demonstration it was unlawful restraint, harassment, and a political litmus test enforced by intimidation.

In an age where dissent is treated like deviance, Nick Shirley is a symbol of restraint and dignity in the face of provocation. His story is not unique, but it is a warning.

The moment we allow mob behavior to decide who can speak, walk, or even exist in public spaces, we’ve traded democracy for something far darker.

(Bethany Baker | The Salt Lake Tribune) Thousands of people gather in front of the Utah Capitol during a protest against the Trump administration in Salt Lake City on Saturday, April 5, 2025.

Let the me be clear:
This is not about left or right. It’s about right and wrong.